The Criminal Procedure (Identification) Act

In Context

  • Recently, the Criminal Procedure (Identification) Act which was passed by the Parliament, came into force.

More about the Criminal Procedure (Identification) Act

  • About:
    • The Act replaces the similar colonial-era Identification of Prisoners Act, 1920.
    • The new law allows investigators to collect certain identifiable information of convicts and other persons for purposes of identification and investigation in criminal matters.
  • Key provisions:
    • Legal sanction of data collection:
      • The new law provides a legal sanction to the police to take physical and biological samples of convicts as well as those accused of crimes
      • It empowers police to collect : 

 

 

  • Persons in preventive detention:
    • The Act also seeks to apply to persons detained under any preventive detention law. 
  • Role of National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB):
    • The law also empowers the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) to store, preserve, share with any law enforcement agency and destroy the record of measurements at the national level. 
    • The records can be stored up to a period of 75 years

The old vs new law:

  • The old law allowed police authorities to take only fingerprint and footprint impressions of a limited category of convicted persons, 
    • Whereas the new law allows police to collect a range of physical and biological samples, not only of convicts but also of those arrested or even detained under any preventive detention law. 
  • While the old law was limited to serious offenders, the new one includes all categories of criminals and accused.

 

  • Punishment:
    • It also does away with the condition of an offence being punishable by at least one year or more of imprisonment for the “measurements” to be taken.
    • Exemptions:
      • It only grants an exemption in the form of mandatory consent for “biological samples”, except in cases where the accused is arrested for sexual abuse of women and children or for an offence carrying a minimum punishment of seven years.
  • Powers of Magistrate: 
    • Under the act, a Magistrate may direct a person to give details for the purpose of an investigation or proceeding under the CrPC
    • Depending on certain factors (such as the area concerned), the Magistrate may be a Metropolitan Magistrate, a Judicial Magistrate of the first class, or an Executive Magistrate
  • Records of juveniles:
    • The Act does not explicitly bar taking measurements of juveniles.
    • The provisions of the (Special Act) Juvenile Justice Act, 2015 regarding the destruction of records of conviction under the Act, shall apply. 

Significance of the Bill

  • The act utilises modern state of Art Technology to collect information. 
    • For example, retina scan, biometrics etc along with previously present fingertips scanning.
    • The use of better technology will only help in minimising the probability of errors
  • It proposes to ensure that no person involved in a political agitation has to give (physical and biometric) measurements only for political agitation. 
    • But, if a political leader is arrested in a criminal case, then he will have to be at par with a citizen.
  • It suits the changing nature of the crime.
  • It proposes to strengthen the capacity of the police and forensic department.

Criticisms

  • Narco analysis and brain mapping:
    • The Opposition expressed apprehension that the words “biological samples and their analysis” mentioned in the Act could allow authorities to perform narco analysis and brain mapping
  • Opaqueness: 
    • The purpose for which the measurements are to be collected, stored, preserved or shared is absent, making the act ambiguous and opaque.
    • Period for which such measurements shall be retained, and grounds for their removal and destruction, are all procedural safeguards that the parent statute must itself lay down but are not there.
  • Use of force:
    • It alleged that the Act will empower authorities to forcefully take measurements of accused and detainees, which it said violates the rights of prisoners violates a catena of Supreme Court judgments. 
  • Over delegation of powers & surveillance state: 
    • Excessive delegation of power is given to various functionaries and authorities under the act , including prison officers and the police. 
    • Some critics touted the act as a step in the direction of becoming a surveillance state.
  • In conflict with the constitution:
    • A regulatory and scientific examination of the act clearly indicates grave constitutional violations as it falls short of the fundamental right to equality (provided by Article 14), the right against self-incrimination (provided by Article 20(3)), and the right to privacy (provided by Article 21) of the Constitution of India.
      • If an infringement of the right to privacy satisfies the test of the doctrine of proportionality as laid down in Puttaswamy II, it can be said to be constitutional. 
      • The doctrine of proportionality constitutes a (i) legitimate aim, (ii) suitable means, (iii) necessity of means, and (iv) proportionality stricto sensu.

Way ahead

  • Safeguard against misuse:
    • The government has assured that the rules would have safeguards against any misuse of the identification database and biological samples, by fixing accountability of those entrusted with the safety of data. 
  • Strengthening criminal procedure:
    • The government views this law as a means to strengthen criminal procedure by consolidating evidence and data at the central level to increase conviction rates
  • Recommendations:
    • To facilitate identification and investigation in criminal matters, Enforcement agencies must be allowed to use scientific methods to prevent and detect crime
      • Necessary training should be imparted to the investigating officers.

It should be ensured that Right to Privacy should be maintained along with keeping national security as the prime agenda.

 
Next article Stablecoins

Other News of the Day

In News Recently, China launched aggressive and unprecedented military exercises near Taiwan in response to US House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s visit to the island that China claims as part of its territory. About porcupine strategy Overall Defence Concept  It was adopted by Taiwan in 2017 when Lee Hsi-Ming, then-chief of the Taiwanese military forces, referred...
Read More

In News Recently, the Ministry of Women and Child Development has informed the Parliamentary Committee on Empowerment of Women that the funds under the ‘Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao’ scheme were underutilised in the early years of the scheme due to lack of awareness and information. About Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao It is a flagship scheme...
Read More

In Context Ocean thermal energy conversion plant coming up in Lakshadweep. About Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion plant (OTEC) Ministry: The National Institute of Ocean Technology, an autonomous institute under the Union Ministry of Earth Sciences (MoES) is establishing an Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion plant. Location: It is being established in Kavaratti, the capital of Lakshadweep....
Read More

In News Recently, a Bill to amend a 20-year law, the Energy Conservation Act 2001, was introduced in Parliament. About  The Energy Conservation (Amendment) Bill, 2022, seeks to mandate: Use of non-fossil sources, including biomass and ethanol for energy and feedstock Use of green hydrogen and green ammonia. Objectives:  To make it compulsory for a...
Read More

In News Recently, the Assam government made a request to include Lachit Borphukan’s valour in textbooks.   Image Courtesy: TN    Lachit Borphukan Born: on November 24, 1622 in Charaideo, the first capital of the Ahom kings.  Led two battles against an alien Mughal army. Battle of Alaboi: Fought on August 5, 1669 in the...
Read More

In News Recently, the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) of the Reserve Bank of India hiked the policy repo rate by 50 basis points to 5.4 per cent, a three-year high owing to inflation concern. What is the Dovish and Hawkish View of Monetary Policy? Dovish View of Monetary Policy Doves support the idea of low-interest...
Read More

In News Recently, the Union government has found that 70 lakh beneficiaries under the National Food Security Act (NFSA) are suspect. Key Points Very recently, a similar exercise has been done and around 70 lakh beneficiaries have been found to be suspected and now that data has been again pushed to respective states to do...
Read More

In Context The Supreme Court recently underlined that marital status should not influence the right to terminate a pregnancy. Observations of SC The Supreme Court said it may loosen the restrictions of a 51-year-old abortion law which bars unmarried women from terminating pregnancies which are up to 24 weeks old. SC said that the prohibition...
Read More